Laser interstitial thermal therapy as an adjunct therapy in brain tumors: A meta-Analysis and comparison with stereotactic radiotherapy

Carregando...
Imagem de Miniatura
Citações na Scopus
7
Tipo de produção
article
Data de publicação
2020
Título da Revista
ISSN da Revista
Título do Volume
Editora
SCIENTIFIC SCHOLAR
Autores
Citação
SURGICAL NEUROLOGY INTERNATIONAL, v.11, p.1-15, 2020
Projetos de Pesquisa
Unidades Organizacionais
Fascículo
Resumo
Background: Minimally invasive procedures are gaining widespread acceptance in difficult-To-Access brain tumor treatment. Stereotactic radiosurgery (SRS) is the preferred choice, however, laser interstitial thermal therapy (LITT) has emerged as a tumor cytoreduction technique. The present meta-Analysis compared current SRS therapy with LITT in brain tumors. Methods: A search was performed in Lilacs, PubMed, and Cochrane database. Patient s demographics, tumor location, therapy used, Karnofsky performance status score before treatment, and patient s outcome (median overall survival, progression-free survival, and adverse events) data were extracted from studies. The risk of bias was assessed by Cochrane collaboration tool. Results: Twenty-five studies were included in this meta-Analysis. LITT and SRS MOS in brain metastasis patients were 12.8 months versus 9.8 months (ranges 9.3-16.3 and 8.3-9.8; P = 0.02), respectively. In a combined comparison of adverse effects among LITT versus SRS in brain metastasis, we found 15% reduction in absolute risk difference (-0.16; 95% confidence interval P < 0.0001). Conclusion: We could not state that LITT treatment is an optimal alternative therapy for difficult-To-Access brain tumors due to the lack of systematic data that were reported in our pooled studies. However, our results identified a positive effect in lowering the absolute risk of adverse events compared with SRS therapy. Therefore, randomized trials are encouraged to ascertain LITT role, as upfront or postoperative/post-SRS therapy for brain tumor treatment. © 2021 National Electronic-Information Consortium (NEICON). All rights reserved.
Palavras-chave
Brain metastasis, Brain tumor, Laser interstitial thermal therapy, Outcome, Recurrent GBM
Referências
  1. Ahmad, S, Ricco, A, Brown, R, Hanlon, A, Yang, J, Feng, J, Single institutional experience of stereotactic radiosurgery alone for first brain metastatic event and salvage of second brain metastatic event in a community setting with review of the literature (2017) Front Oncol, 7, p. 32
  2. Al-Zabin, M, Ullrich, WO, Brawanski, A, Proescholdt, MA., Recurrent brain metastases from lung cancer: The impact of reoperation (2010) Acta Neurochir (Wien), 152, pp. 1887-1892
  3. Atalar, B, Choi, CY, Harsh, GR, Chang, SD, Gibbs, IC, Adler, JR, Cavity volume dynamics after resection of brain metastases and timing of postresection cavity stereotactic radiosurgery (2013) Neurosurgery, 72, pp. 180-185
  4. Badie, B, Brooks, N, Souweidane, MM., Endoscopic and minimally invasive microsurgical approaches for treating brain tumor patients (2004) J Neurooncol, 69, pp. 209-219
  5. Bezjak, A, Adam, J, Barton, R, Panzarella, T, Laperriere, N, Wong, CS, Symptom response after palliative radiotherapy for patients with brain metastases (2002) Eur J Cancer, 38, pp. 487-496
  6. Bindal, RK, Sawaya, R, Leavens, ME, Hess, KR, Taylor, SH., Reoperation for recurrent metastatic brain tumors (1995) J Neurosurg, 83, pp. 600-604
  7. Bown, SG., Phototherapy of tumors (1983) World J Surg, 7, pp. 700-709
  8. Brown, JM, Carlson, DJ, Brenner, DJ., The tumor radiobiology of SRS and SBRT: Are more than the 5 Rs involved? (2014) Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys, 88, pp. 254-262
  9. Brown, PD, Ballman, KV, Cerhan, JH, Anderson, SK, Carrero, XW, Whitton, AC, Postoperative stereotactic radiosurgery compared with whole brain radiotherapy for resected metastatic brain disease (NCCTG N107C/CEC 3): A multicentre, randomised, controlled, phase 3 trial (2017) Lancet Oncol, 18, pp. 1049-1060
  10. Caballero, JA, Sneed, PK, Lamborn, KR, Ma, L, Denduluri, S, Nakamura, JL, Prognostic factors for survival in patients treated with stereotactic radiosurgery for recurrent brain metastases after prior whole brain radiotherapy (2012) Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys, 83, pp. 303-309
  11. Caissie, A, Nguyen, J, Chen, E, Zhang, L, Sahgal, A, Clemons, M, Quality of life in patients with brain metastases using the EORTC QLQ-BN20+2 and QLQ-C15-PAL (2012) Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys, 83, pp. 1238-1245
  12. Carpentier, A, McNichols, RJ, Stafford, RJ, Guichard, JP, Reizine, D, Delaloge, S, Laser thermal therapy: Real-Time MRI-guided and computer-controlled procedures for metastatic brain tumors (2011) Lasers Surg Med, 43, pp. 943-950
  13. (2020) Optimizing Supply of PPE and Other Equipment During Shortages, , https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/hcp/ppe-strategy/index.html, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Healthcare Work
  14. [Last accessed on 2020 Aug 31]
  15. Chao, ST, Barnett, GH, Vogelbaum, MA, Angelov, L, Weil, RJ, Neyman, G, Salvage stereotactic radiosurgery effectively treats recurrences from whole-brain radiation therapy (2008) Cancer, 113, pp. 2198-2204
  16. DerSimonian, R, Laird, N., Meta-Analysis in clinical trials (1986) Control Clin Trials, 7, pp. 177-188
  17. Dodoo, E, Huffmann, B, Peredo, I, Grinaker, H, Sinclair, G, Machinis, T, Increased survival using delayed gamma knife radiosurgery for recurrent high-grade glioma: A feasibility study (2014) World Neurosurg, 82, pp. e623-e632
  18. Elliott, RE, Parker, EC, Rush, SC, Kalhorn, SP, Moshel, YA, Narayana, A, Efficacy of gamma knife radiosurgery for small-volume recurrent malignant gliomas after initial radical resection (2011) World Neurosurg, 76, pp. 128-140
  19. Faruqi, S, Ruschin, M, Soliman, H, Myrehaug, S, Zeng, KL, Husain, Z, Adverse radiation effect after hypofractionated stereotactic radiosurgery in 5 daily fractions for surgical cavities and intact brain metastases (2020) Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys, 106, pp. 772-779
  20. Fine, HA, Puduvalli, VK, Chamberlain, MC, Carpentier, AF, Cher, L, Mason, WP, Enzastaurin (ENZ) versus lomustine (CCNU) in the treatment of recurrent, intracranial glioblastoma multiforme (GBM): A phase III study (2008) J Clin Oncol, 26, p. 2005
  21. Follwell, MJ, Khu, KJ, Cheng, L, Xu, W, Mikulis, DJ, Millar, BA, Volume specific response criteria for brain metastases following salvage stereotactic radiosurgery and associated predictors of response (2012) Acta Oncol, 51, pp. 629-635
  22. Fox, SW, Lyon, D, Farace, E., Symptom clusters in patients with high-grade glioma (2007) J Nurs Scholarsh, 39, pp. 61-67
  23. Gaspar, L, Scott, C, Rotman, M, Asbell, S, Phillips, T, Wasserman, T, Recursive partitioning analysis (RPA) of prognostic factors in three radiation therapy oncology group (RTOG) brain metastases trials (1997) Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys, 37, pp. 745-751
  24. Gustafsson, M, Edvardsson, T, Ahlström, G., The relationship between function, quality of life and coping in patients with low-grade gliomas (2006) Support Care Cancer, 14, pp. 1205-1212
  25. Hanssens, P, Karlsson, B, Vashu, R, Yeo, TT, Beute, G., Salvage treatment of distant recurrent brain metastases with gamma knife surgery (2012) Acta Neurochir (Wien), 154, pp. 285-290
  26. Harris, S, Chan, MD, Lovato, JF, Ellis, TL, Tatter, SB, Bourland, JD, Gamma knife stereotactic radiosurgery as salvage therapy after failure of whole-brain radiotherapy in patients with small-cell lung cancer (2012) Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys, 83, pp. e53-e59
  27. Hasan, S, Chen, E, Lanciano, R, Yang, J, Hanlon, A, Lamond, J, Salvage fractionated stereotactic radiotherapy with or without chemotherapy and immunotherapy for recurrent glioblastoma multiforme: A single institution experience (2015) Front Oncol, 5, p. 106
  28. Hawasli, AH, Bagade, S, Shimony, JS, Miller-Thomas, M, Leuthardt, EC., Magnetic resonance imaging-guided focused laser interstitial thermal therapy for intracranial lesions (2013) Neurosurgery, 73, pp. 1007-1017
  29. Higgins, JPT, Altman, DG, Gøtzsche, PC, Jöni, P, Moher, D, Oxman, AD, The cochrane collaboration s tool for assessing risk of bias in randomised trials (2011) BMJ, 343, p. d5928
  30. Higuchi, Y, Yamamoto, M, Serizawa, T, Aiyama, H, Sato, Y, Barfod, BE., Modern management for brain metastasis patients using stereotactic radiosurgery: Literature review and the authors gamma knife treatment experiences (2018) Cancer Manag Res, 10, pp. 1889-1899
  31. Holt, D, Bernard, M, Quan, K, Clump, D, Engh, J, Burton, S, Salvage stereotactic radiosurgery for recurrent glioblastoma multiforme with prior radiation therapy (2016) J Cancer Res Ther, 12, pp. 1243-1248
  32. Hozo, SP, Djulbegovic, B, Hozo, I., Estimating the mean and variance from the median, range, and the size of a sample (2005) BMC Med Res Methodol, 5, p. 13
  33. Hughes, RT, Black, PJ, Page, BR, Lucas, JT, Qasem, SA, Watabe, K, Local control of brain metastases after stereotactic radiosurgery: The impact of whole brain radiotherapy and treatment paradigm (2016) J Radiosurg SBRT, 4, pp. 89-96
  34. Hui, X, Haider, AH, Hashmi, ZG, Rushing, AP, Dhiman, N, Scott, VK, Increased risk of pneumonia among ventilated patients with traumatic brain injury: Every day counts! (2013) J Surg Res, 184, pp. 438-443
  35. Jethwa, PR, Barrese, JC, Gowda, A, Shetty, A, Danish, SF., Magnetic resonance thermometry-guided laser-induced thermal therapy for intracranial neoplasms (2012) Neurosurgery, 71, pp. 133-144. , Suppl 1:-
  36. 144-5
  37. Johnson, MD, Avkshtol, V, Baschnagel, AM, Meyer, K, Ye, H, Grills, IS, Surgical resection of brain metastases and the risk of leptomeningeal recurrence in patients treated with stereotactic radiosurgery (2016) Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys, 94, pp. 537-543
  38. Kamath, AA, Friedman, DD, Hacker, CD, Smyth, MD, Limbrick, DD, Kim, AH, MRI-guided interstitial laser ablation for intracranial lesions: A large single-institution experience of 133 cases (2017) Stereotact Funct Neurosurg, 95, pp. 417-428
  39. Katipally, R, Koffer, PP, Rava, PS, Cielo, D, Toms, SA, DiPetrillo, TA, Surgical resection and posterior fossa location increase the incidence of leptomeningeal disease in patients treated with stereotactic radiosurgery for brain metastases (2017) Int J Radiat Oncol, 99, p. S173
  40. Kaye, J, Patel, NV, Danish, SF., Laser interstitial thermal therapy for in-field recurrence of brain metastasis after stereotactic radiosurgery: Does treatment with LITT prevent a neurologic death? (2020) Clin Exp Metastasis, 37, pp. 435-444
  41. Kelly, PJ, Lin, NU, Claus, EB, Quant, EC, Weiss, SE, Alexander, BM., Salvage stereotactic radiosurgery for breast cancer brain metastases: Outcomes and prognostic factors (2012) Cancer, 118, pp. 2014-2020
  42. Kim, EY, Yechieli, R, Kim, JK, Mikkelsen, T, Kalkanis, SN, Rock, J, Patterns of failure after radiosurgery to two different target volumes of enhancing lesions with and without FLAIR abnormalities in recurrent glioblastoma multiforme (2014) J Neurooncol, 116, pp. 291-297
  43. Kim, HR, Kim, KH, Kong, DS, Seol, HJ, Nam, DH, Lim, DH, Outcome of salvage treatment for recurrent glioblastoma (2015) J Clin Neurosci, 22, pp. 468-473
  44. Komosinska, K, Kepka, L, Niwinska, A, Pietrzak, L, Wierzchowski, M, Tyc-Szczepaniak, D, Prospective evaluation of the palliative effect of whole-brain radiotherapy in patients with brain metastases and poor performance status (2010) Acta Oncol, 49, pp. 382-388
  45. Kondziolka, D, Kano, H, Harrison, GL, Yang, HC, Liew, DN, Niranjan, A, Stereotactic radiosurgery as primary and salvage treatment for brain metastases from breast cancer. Clinical article (2011) J Neurosurg, 114, pp. 792-800
  46. Kong, W, Jarvis, CR, Sutton, DS, Ding, K, Mackillop, WJ., The use of palliative whole brain radiotherapy in the management of brain metastases (2012) Clin Oncol (R Coll Radiol), 24, pp. e149-e158
  47. Kotecha, R, Damico, N, Miller, JA, Suh, JH, Murphy, ES, Reddy, CA, Three or more courses of stereotactic radiosurgery for patients with multiply recurrent brain metastases (2017) Neurosurgery, 80, pp. 871-879
  48. Kurtz, G, Zadeh, G, Gingras-Hill, G, Millar, BA, Laperriere, NJ, Bernstein, M, Salvage radiosurgery for brain metastases: Prognostic factors to consider in patient selection (2014) Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys, 88, pp. 137-142
  49. Kwekkeboom, KL., Cancer symptom cluster management (2016) Semin Oncol Nurs, 32, pp. 373-382
  50. Lamba, N, Muskens, IS, DiRisio, AC, Meijer, L, Briceno, V, Edrees, H, Stereotactic radiosurgery versus whole-brain radiotherapy after intracranial metastasis resection: A systematic review and meta-Analysis (2017) Radiat Oncol, 12, p. 106
  51. Lamborn, KR, Yung, WK, Chang, SM, Wen, PY, Cloughesy, TF, DeAngelis, LM, Progression-free survival: An important end point in evaluating therapy for recurrent high-grade gliomas (2008) Neuro Oncol, 10, pp. 162-170
  52. van Linde, ME, Brahm, CG, de Witt Hamer, PC, Reijneveld, JC, Bruynzeel, AM, Vandertop, WP, Treatment outcome of patients with recurrent glioblastoma multiforme: A retrospective multicenter analysis (2017) J Neurooncol, 135, pp. 183-192
  53. Mahajan, A, Ahmed, S, McAleer, MF, Weinberg, JS, Li, J, Brown, P, Post-operative stereotactic radiosurgery versus observation for completely resected brain metastases: A single-centre, randomised, controlled, phase 3 trial (2017) Lancet Oncol, 18, pp. 1040-1048
  54. Malone, HR, Bruce, JN., Editorial: Laser interstitial thermal therapy: An effective treatment for focally recurrent high grade glioma (2014) Neurosurg Focus, 37, p. E2
  55. Mandl, ES, Dirven, CM, Buis, DR, Postma, TJ, Vandertop, WP., Repeated surgery for glioblastoma multiforme: Only in combination with other salvage therapy (2008) Surg Neurol, 69, pp. 506-509
  56. Mariya, Y, Sekizawa, G, Matsuoka, Y, Seki, H, Sugawara, T., Outcome of stereotactic radiosurgery for patients with non-small cell lung cancer metastatic to the brain (2010) J Radiat Res, 51, pp. 333-342
  57. McKay, WH, McTyre, ER, Okoukoni, C, Alphonse-Sullivan, NK, Ruiz, J, Munley, MT, Repeat stereotactic radiosurgery as salvage therapy for locally recurrent brain metastases previously treated with radiosurgery (2017) J Neurosurg, 127, pp. 148-156
  58. Miaskowski, C, Barsevick, A, Berger, A, Casagrande, R, Grady, PA, Jacobsen, P, Advancing symptom science through symptom cluster research: Expert panel proceedings and recommendations (2017) J Natl Cancer Inst, 109, p. djw253
  59. Missios, S, Bekelis, K, Barnett, GH., Renaissance of laser interstitial thermal ablation (2015) Neurosurg Focus, 38, p. E13
  60. Mohammadi, AM, Schroeder, JL., Laser interstitial thermal therapy in treatment of brain tumors-The NeuroBlate system (2014) Expert Rev Med Devices, 11, pp. 109-119
  61. Moher, D, Liberati, A, Tetzlaff, J, Altman, DG., Preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-Analyses: The PRISMA statement (2009) Ann Intern Med, 151, pp. 264-269. , W64
  62. Moreau, J, Khalil, T, Dupic, G, Chautard, E, Lemaire, JJ, Magnier, F, Second course of stereotactic radiosurgery for locally recurrent brain metastases: Safety and efficacy (2018) PLoS One, 13, p. e0195608
  63. Muacevic, A, Wowra, B, Siefert, A, Tonn, JC, Steiger, HJ, Kreth, FW., Microsurgery plus whole brain irradiation versus gamma knife surgery alone for treatment of single metastases to the brain: A randomized controlled multicentre Phase III trial (2008) J Neurooncol, 87, pp. 299-307
  64. Murray, KJ, Scott, C, Greenberg, HM, Emami, B, Seider, M, Vora, NL, A randomized phase III study of accelerated hyperfractionation versus standard in patients with unresected brain metastases: A report of the radiation therapy oncology group (RTOG) 9104 (1997) Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys, 39, pp. 571-574
  65. Nakazaki, K, Higuchi, Y, Nagano, O, Serizawa, T., Efficacy and limitations of salvage gamma knife radiosurgery for brain metastases of small-cell lung cancer after whole-brain radiotherapy (2013) Acta Neurochir (Wien), 155, pp. 107-114
  66. Nieder, C, Pawiniski, A, Dalhaug, A., Presentation and outcome in cancer patients with extensive spread to the brain (2009) BMC Res Notes, 2, p. 247
  67. Niranjan, A, Kano, H, Iyer, A, Kondziolka, D, Flickinger, JC, Lunsford, LD., Role of adjuvant or salvage radiosurgery in the management of unresected residual or progressive glioblastoma multiforme in the pre-bevacizumab era (2015) J Neurosurg, 122, pp. 757-765
  68. Osoba, D, Brada, M, Prados, MD, Yung, WK., Effect of disease burden on health-related quality of life in patients with malignant gliomas (2000) Neuro Oncol, 2, pp. 221-228
  69. Owonikoko, TK, Arbiser, J, Zelnak, A, Shu, HK, Shim, H, Robin, AM, Current approaches to the treatment of metastatic brain tumours (2014) Nat Rev Clin Oncol, 11, pp. 203-222
  70. Patel, N V, Jethwa, PR, Barrese, JC, Hargreaves, EL, Danish, SF., Volumetric trends associated with MRI-guided laser-induced thermal therapy (LITT) for intracranial tumors (2013) Lasers Surg Med, 45, pp. 362-369
  71. Pulenzas, N, Khan, L, Tsao, M, Zhang, L, Lechner, B, Thavarajah, N, Fatigue scores in patients with brain metastases receiving whole brain radiotherapy (2014) Support Care Cancer, 22, pp. 1757-1763
  72. Rana, N, Pendyala, P, Cleary, RK, Luo, G, Zhao, Z, Chambless, LB, Long-Term outcomes after salvage stereotactic radiosurgery (SRS) following in-field failure of initial srs for brain metastases (2017) Front Oncol, 7, p. 279
  73. Sadik, ZH, Hanssens, PE, Verheul, JB, Beute, GN, Te Lie, S, Leenstra, S, Gamma knife radiosurgery for recurrent gliomas (2018) J Neurooncol, 140, pp. 615-622
  74. Sanders, J, Nordström, H, Sheehan, J, Schlesinger, D., Gamma knife radiosurgery: Scenarios and support for re-irradiation (2019) Phys Med, 68, pp. 75-82
  75. Schwarzmaier, HJ, Eickmeyer, F, von Tempelhoff, W, Fiedler, VU, Niehoff, H, Ulrich, SD, MR-guided laser irradiation of recurrent glioblastomas (2005) J Magn Reson Imaging, 22, pp. 799-803
  76. Shibamoto, Y, Otsuka, S, Iwata, H, Sugie, C, Ogino, H, Tomita, N., Radiobiological evaluation of the radiation dose as used in high-precision radiotherapy: Effect of prolonged delivery time and applicability of the linear-quadratic model (2012) J Radiat Res, 53, pp. 1-9
  77. Sinclair, G, Benmakhlouf, H, Martin, H, Maeurer, M, Dodoo, E., Adaptive hypofractionated gamma knife radiosurgery in the acute management of brainstem metastases (2019) Surg Neurol Int, 10, p. 14
  78. Sinclair, G, Stenman, M, Benmakhlouf, H, Johnstone, P, Wersäll, P, Lindskog, M, Adaptive radiosurgery based on two simultaneous dose prescriptions in the management of large renal cell carcinoma brain metastases in critical areas: Towards customization (2020) Surg Neurol Int, 11, p. 21
  79. Sloan, AE, Ahluwalia, MS, Valerio-Pascua, J, Manjila, S, Torchia, MG, Jones, SE, Results of the NeuroBlate system first-in-humans Phase I clinical trial for recurrent glioblastoma: Clinical article (2013) J Neurosurg, 118, pp. 1202-1219
  80. Soliman, H, Ruschin, M, Angelov, L, Brown, PD, Chiang, VL, Kirkpatrick, JP, Consensus contouring guidelines for postoperative completely resected cavity stereotactic radiosurgery for brain metastases (2018) Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys, 100, pp. 436-442
  81. Soltys, SG, Gibbs, IC, Chang, SD, Adler, JR, Harsh, GR, Lieberson, RE, Stereotactic radiosurgery of the post-operative resection cavity for brain metastases: Optimization of the treatment technique (2010) Int J Radiat Oncol, 78, p. S7
  82. Song, Z, Zhang, Y., Gefitinib and erlotinib for non-small cell lung cancer patients who fail to respond to radiotherapy for brain metastases (2014) J Clin Neurosci, 21, pp. 591-595
  83. omas, JG, Rao, G, Kew, Y, Prabhu, SS., Laser interstitial thermal therapy for newly diagnosed and recurrent glioblastoma (2016) Neurosurg Focus, 41, p. E12
  84. Tsao, MN, Xu, W, Wong, RK, Lloyd, N, Laperriere, N, Sahgal, A, Whole brain radiotherapy for the treatment of newly diagnosed multiple brain metastases (2018) Cochrane Database Syst Rev, 1, p. CD003869
  85. Wellisch, DK, Kaleita, TA, Freeman, D, Cloughesy, T, Goldman, J., Predicting major depression in brain tumor patients (2002) Psychooncology, 11, pp. 230-238
  86. Yamamoto, M, Serizawa, T, Shuto, T, Akabane, A, Higuchi, Y, Kawagishi, J, Stereotactic radiosurgery for patients with multiple brain metastases (JLGK0901): A multi-institutional prospective observational study (2014) Lancet Oncol, 15, pp. 387-395
  87. Yomo, S, Hayashi, M., The efficacy and limitations of stereotactic radiosurgery as a salvage treatment after failed whole brain radiotherapy for brain metastases (2013) J Neurooncol, 113, pp. 459-465
  88. Zimmerman, AL, Murphy, ES, Suh, JH, Vogelbaum, MA, Barnett, GH, Angelov, L, Treatment of large brain metastases with stereotactic radiosurgery Technol Cancer Res Treat